We investigate the rank gain of elliptic curves, and more generally, Jacobian varieties, over non-Galois extensions whose Galois closure has a Galois group permutation-isomorphic to a prescribed group G (in short, "G-extensions"). In particular, for alternating groups and (an infinite family of) projective linear groups G, we show that most elliptic curves over (for example) Q$\mathbb {Q}$ gain rank over infinitely many G-extensions, conditional only on the parity conjecture. More generally, we provide a theoretical criterion, which allows to deduce that "many" elliptic curves gain rank over infinitely many G-extensions, conditional on the parity conjecture and on the existence of geometric Galois realizations with group G and certain local properties.