We describe the total synthesis of epoxyquinoid natural products (+)-pestalofone A and (+)-iso-A82775C. The synthesis of (+)-16-oxo-iso-A82775C, the putative biosynthetic precursor of pestalofone C, is also presented. The allene moiety present in (+)-iso-A82775C and (+)-16-oxo-iso-A82775C was constructed from the ketodiene-yne group via a biosynthetically relevant sequence involving a conjugate reduction and a basecatalyzed tautomerization. Attempted Diels−Alder reaction-based dimerizations of (+)-16-oxo-iso-A82775C and (+)-iso-A82775C toward pestalofones B and C are also described.