When Do Matthew Effects Occur?

Cited 35 time in webofscience Cited 0 time in scopus
  • Hit : 495
  • Download : 0
What are the boundary conditions of the Matthew Effect? In other words, under what circumstances do initial status differences result in highly skewed reward distributions over the long run, and when, conversely, is the accumulation of status-based advantages constrained? Using a formal model, we investigate the fates of actors in a contest who start off as status-equivalents, produce at different levels of quality, and thus come to occupy distinct locations in a status ordering. We build from a set of equations in which failing to observe cumulative advantage seems implausible and then demonstrate that, despite initial conditions designed to lead inevitably to status monopolization, circumstances still exist that rein in the Matthew Effect. Our results highlight the importance of a single factor governing whether the Matthew Effect operates freely or is circumscribed. This factor is the degree to which status diffuses through social relations. When actors' status levels are strongly influenced by the status levels of those dispensing recognition to them, then eventually the top-ranked actor is nearly matched in status by the lower-ranked actor she endorses. In contrast, when actors' status levels are unaffected by the status levels of those giving them recognition, the top-ranked actor amasses virtually all status available in the system. Our primary contribution is the intuition that elites may unwittingly and paradoxically destroy their cumulative advantage beneath the weight of their endorsements of others. Consequently, we find that the Matthew Effect is curtailed by a process that, at least in some social settings, is a property of status itselfits propensity to diffuse through social relations. Implications for future research are discussed.
Publisher
TAYLOR & FRANCIS INC
Issue Date
2010
Language
English
Article Type
Article
Keywords

ACCUMULATIVE ADVANTAGE; RED QUEEN; INDUSTRY; INEQUALITY; MARKET; STRATIFICATION; COMPETITION; NETWORKS; MOBILITY; SUCCESS

Citation

JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICAL SOCIOLOGY, v.34, pp.80 - 114

ISSN
0022-250X
DOI
10.1080/00222500903310960
URI
http://hdl.handle.net/10203/214660
Appears in Collection
GCT-Journal Papers(저널논문)
Files in This Item
There are no files associated with this item.
This item is cited by other documents in WoS
⊙ Detail Information in WoSⓡ Click to see webofscience_button
⊙ Cited 35 items in WoS Click to see citing articles in records_button

qr_code

  • mendeley

    citeulike


rss_1.0 rss_2.0 atom_1.0